Pop is suffering from the same malady as the art world, which is stuck on the tired old rubric that shock automatically confers value. But those once powerful avant-garde gestures have lost their relevance in our diffuse and technology-saturated era, when there is no longer an ossified high-culture establishment to rebel against. On the contrary, the fine arts are alarmingly distant or marginal to most young people today.
Unfortunately, the media spotlight so cheaply won by Cyrus will inevitably spur repeats of her silly stunt, by her and others. Image and profile now rule the music industry. At a time when profits are coming far more from touring than from CD sales, performers are being hammered too early into a marketable formula for cavernous sports venues. With their massive computerized lighting and special-effects systems, arena shows make improvisation impossible and stifle the natural rapport with the audience that performers once had in vaudeville houses and jazz clubs. There is neither time nor space to develop emotional depth or creative skills.
Pop is an artistic tradition that deserves as much respect as any other. Its lineage stretches back to 17th century Appalachian folk songs and African-American blues, all of which can still be heard vibrating in the lyrics and chord structure of contemporary music. But our most visible young performers, consumed with packaging and attitude, seem to have little sense of that thrilling continuity and therefore no confidence in how it can define and sustain their artistic identities over the course of a career.
I think the phrase that pays nowadays is "unsustainable".
I love when Boomers pretend that - after their kids witnessed their antics - they now have no idea where any of this is coming from.
But - they also assure us - there's nothing that can be done.
It's just so neat and tidy,...
Fortunately my husband and I are not Boomers, and our son is currently in love with Nina Simone (and that should say as much for his sisters).
ReplyDeleteIt's a start -- if we want to change how it's going, we have to encourage kids to listen to a lot of different things other than what's currently on the radio. One kid and one step at a time.
PW
PS. My six year old loves "Babylon.com"...just thought I'd share that. "Play that Babylon song again...'I just want to pay my rent!'" So while she likes to sing along to "Fireworks" because she's six, she also likes other music too. The 5 yo. likes Kazakh folk music...